Quick Take
All certified bats perform within 5% of each other. The 'hottest bat' marketing is BS. Pick based on feel, swing weight, and price—performance is basically identical.
We’ve all seen posts online claiming which bat is the best in each category, usually focusing on performance. While everyone is entitled to their opinion, this article takes a different approach, acknowledging that “best” often depends on individual needs and preferences.
Performance Testing: The Truth About High-End Bats
The truth is, most high-end non-wood performance bats today test near the maximum allowable limit in their category (BBCOR, USSSA, ASA, USA Baseball). Whether it’s the Warstic Bonesaber, Select PWR from Slugger, DeMarini’s Voodoo One, or Easton’s ROPE, performance testing using a cannon (measuring BBCOR or performance at specific barrel locations) reveals only marginal differences.
Differentiating Traits: Beyond Performance
While performance is important, several other traits set bats apart, including:
- Sound: How the bat feels to the ear.
- Feel: The tactile feedback from hitting.
- MOI (Swing Weight): A critical factor affecting swing speed and strength.
- Barrel Profile/Shape: Impacts hitting surface area and usability.
- Graphics: Aesthetic appeal, though subjective.
MOI: Understanding Swing Weight
Moment of Inertia (MOI) directly influences a hitter’s performance:
- A balanced bat suits players focusing on control and gap shots.
- An end-loaded bat provides more power but requires more swing speed and strength.
Choosing the right MOI can ensure optimal performance based on your swing type and goals.
Barrel Profiles: More Than Just a Shape
Barrel profile differences might seem minor, but they matter. When comparing bats of the same length and weight:
- Check where the barrel begins to taper off.
- A longer barrel increases hitting surface area, offering better forgiveness and control.
Trying Before Buying: Why It Matters
Testing a bat before purchasing can make a big difference. Here’s how to get started:
- Narrow Down Your Options: Research 2-4 bats that align with your swing.
- Explore Demo Opportunities:
- Contact manufacturers for demo centers.
- Visit local retailers and ask about test models.
- Request retailers to reach out to sales reps for demo setups.
Putting in this effort can help you make a more informed decision and avoid relying solely on random online reviews.
Conclusion: Make an Informed Choice
Finding the best bat isn’t just about picking the most popular model. You can find one that truly fits your swing and preferences by understanding performance testing, considering unique traits like MOI and barrel profiles, and trying out bats when possible.
