When it comes to contact sports, having the right protective gear is crucial, and one of the most important pieces is a reliable athletic cup. Below are some of the best athletic cups for baseball players options on the market, along with their pros, cons, and pricing, to help you make an informed decision.
Comfy Cup
The Comfy Cup is essentially a soft, slightly padded cup offering minimal protection. It’s better than wearing just briefs, making it a beginner-friendly option. However, it won’t stand up well to hard, direct hits and is more suited for younger players who are just starting to use protective gear.
Price: $15
Pros:
- Comfortable (Soft, slightly padded)
- Better than briefs
Cons:
- Limited protection against strong impacts
- Small capacity (“Holds like 8 grapes”)
- Strictly a boys cup
Shock Doctor Cup
The Shock Doctor flex cup is widely available and offers an affordable entry point into protective gear. While it provides basic protection and comes in many designs, its performance in direct impact tests left something to be desired. It’s still a decent option for casual athletes, considering the low price and easy accessibility.
Price: $15
Pros:
- Found in most athletic stores
- Affordable ($10)
- Many colorways and designs
Cons:
- Limited protection (poor grape test results)
- Smaller capacity
- Not significantly different from other basic cups
Diamond MMA
The Diamond MMA cup was designed with mixed martial arts in mind. It fits well, looks professional, and provides decent protection. However, it did not outperform some cheaper options in impact tests. If you’re involved in multiple sports and want a well-fitting, professional-looking cup, this could be a worthy choice—albeit at a higher price.
Price: $70
Pros:
- Versatile for multiple sports
- Professional look
- Great fit
Cons:
- Underperformed cheaper alternatives in tests
- Only modest protection gain
- Pricey option
Nutty Buddy Cup
The Nutty Buddy Cup puts comfort at the forefront. Highly praised for its fit and used by many MLB players, it reduces pinch points and delivers a better wearing experience. Although it costs more than basic cups, its reputation for comfort and MLB endorsement might justify the investment for serious athletes.
Price: $35
Pros:
- Designed for comfort (no pinch points)
- Used by MLB players
- Great fit for those who struggle with standard cups
Cons:
- Higher price than most basic cups
- May be harder to find at times
- Focuses heavily on comfort over other features
Buy on Nutty Buddy | Buy on eBay
McDavid Athletic Cup
The McDavid Athletic Cup is a straightforward, no-frills protective solution. It’s cost-effective, offers surprisingly effective protection, and even accommodates a slightly larger area. At under $10, it provides the best bang for your buck, especially for players just looking for a solid basic cup.
Price: $12
Pros:
- Very affordable (under $10)
- Great protection (best in testing)
- Larger size than comparable options
Cons:
- No extra features or frills
- Basic brand perception
- Focuses solely on functionality
