Catchers take a lot of abuse behind the plate, and one body part is particularly prone to injury: the thumb. A catcher’s thumb guard helps prevent hyper-extension and minimize the impact from foul tips or high-velocity throws. While many players may not need one until they start facing harder-throwing pitchers, investing in a good thumb guard (or similar protective gear) can make a huge difference in comfort and performance. Below are some of the best options, pros, and cons.
Catcher’s Thumb
The Catcher’s Thumb is a specialized thumb guard that uses a plastic device fitted directly to the thumb. While it may be more complicated to form than an EvoShield—requiring measuring, cutting, and trimming—it provides a hard shell of protection once set. Just be cautious when trimming; too much alteration can ruin the guard.
Price: $35
Pros:
- Really works.
- Durable
Cons:
- Takes effort to form correctly
- Not widely accessible (only on their site)
Wilson Catcher’s Glove
If thumb pain is an issue, consider investing in a top-tier catcher’s mitt instead of a thumb guard. Wilson’s elite-level gloves are designed to handle serious pitching velocity, potentially making a separate guard unnecessary. Although expensive and requiring a break-in period, the quality and protection can be worth the investment.
Price: $350
Pros:
- Awesome quality
- Pro-level craftsmanship
Cons:
- Expensive
- Harder to break in
All Stars Inner Glove
If you’re more interested in reducing sting than specifically protecting the thumb, an All Stars inner protective glove could do the trick. Similar to a batting glove but with added foam in high-impact zones, it takes the brunt of the force while catching. While not strictly a thumb guard, it provides general hand protection that can alleviate thumb discomfort.
Price: $22
Pros:
- Cheap
- Effective
- Versatile
Cons:
- Not specifically a thumb guard
Endoskel
The Endoskel takes a unique approach: instead of fitting around your thumb, it slides into the glove’s thumb slot. It’s an aluminum/alloy piece wrapped in foam and rubber, staying inside the glove at all times. This means no worries about losing it. It’s affordable and effective, though it may not carry the brand recognition of more common options.
Price: $30
Pros:
- Inexpensive
- Adaptable
- Works well
Cons:
- Not as well-known as EvoShield
Evoshield Thumb Guard
The EvoShield thumb protector is one of the most popular options on the market. It is easy to find, relatively affordable at about $25, and simple to form—just follow their instructions or watch a how-to video. The gel hardens into a shell that perfectly fits your thumb, providing solid protection without too much fuss.
Price: $25
Pros:
- Really works
- Highly rated
- Easily accessible
Cons:
- Not the cheapest option
